Crime & Justice · Sep 12, 2026Fourth Circuit Becomes Ninth Court to Reject ICE No-Bond Detention

KEMETIC MINDS
ICE Watch — Daily Update — September 12, 2026

---

A federal appeals court ruled Friday that the government cannot lock up people facing deportation without giving them a chance to ask for release on bond — and it compared the policy to one of the darkest chapters in U.S. history (EL PAÍS English, 2026).

In the same 24-hour window, ICE detained workers at a Pennsylvania hospital construction site and arrested five campers on public land in Washington state (MSN, 2026).

• The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that the government cannot require mandatory detention for people in deportation proceedings without a bond hearing — the ninth federal appeals court to reject the practice (EL PAÍS English, 2026).
• Judge Nicole Berner wrote that “mass detention of marginalized individuals without due process harkens back to some of the darkest moments in our country’s history” (EL PAÍS English, 2026).
• Only two federal appeals courts have backed the government’s reading of the law, a split that raises the odds the Supreme Court will decide the question (EL PAÍS English, 2026).
• ICE detained multiple people at a construction site for a Geisinger Medical Center project in Montour County, Pennsylvania (MSN, 2026).
• Five men camping on public land in Washington were arrested with help from U.S. Forest Service rangers; their families say ICE targeted the group (MSN, 2026).
• In Frederick, Maryland, political leaders are calling for investigations after video showed ICE officers using batons on protesters (The Guardian, 2026).
• An El Paso exhibit marking one year of Camp East Montana was designed by people who were detained there (NBC News, 2026).

1. ICE Raids a Pennsylvania Hospital Project and a Washington Campsite

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement detained multiple people at a construction site tied to a Geisinger Medical Center project in Montour County, Pennsylvania, according to reporting from local station WBRE/WYOU (MSN, 2026).

How many people were taken into custody, and where they were moved afterward, is not stated in the report (MSN, 2026).

Rangers joined an arrest on public land

In Washington state, five men camping on public lands were arrested by ICE with assistance from U.S. Forest Service rangers, according to their families (MSN, 2026).

The families say ICE agents targeted the group while they were camping. No agency statement on the arrests appears in the source material.

The open question is whether these were isolated actions or part of a wider push — and whether federal land agencies will keep assisting immigration enforcement on the ground. Our earlier reporting on a large Pennsylvania raid and the legal pushback it triggered is here.

---

2. A Replica of Camp East Montana, Built by People Who Lived There

Camp East Montana opened at Fort Bliss, Texas, one year ago (NBC News, 2026).

To mark the anniversary, groups and activists in El Paso built an immersive replica of the facility — designed by people who were detained inside it (NBC News, 2026).

The exhibit is an attempt to show visitors what detention is like from the inside, told by the people who lived it (NBC News, 2026).

What no exhibit can settle is whether conditions inside Camp East Montana have changed since it opened. That question is not answered in the source material.

---

3. Fourth Circuit Becomes Ninth Court to Reject No-Bond Detention

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that the government cannot interpret immigration law to allow mandatory detention of millions of people in deportation proceedings, denying them the chance to seek release on bond (EL PAÍS English, 2026).

The effect in this circuit is concrete: people fighting deportation cannot be held without being allowed to ask for bond (EL PAÍS English, 2026).

What the majority wrote

Judge Nicole Berner wrote the majority opinion, joined by Judge Barbara Keenan (EL PAÍS English, 2026).

Berner compared the measure’s reach to the mass internment of Japanese Americans during World War II, calling it a “historical stain,” and cited the late 19th century detention of Chinese immigrants as another precedent (EL PAÍS English, 2026).

“Mass detention of marginalized individuals without due process harkens back to some of the darkest moments in our country’s history,” she wrote (EL PAÍS English, 2026).

Nine courts, two dissents, one likely destination

The Fourth Circuit is the ninth federal appeals court to reject the administration’s interpretation. Only two appeals courts have backed it (EL PAÍS English, 2026).

That split greatly increases the chances the dispute reaches the Supreme Court, according to the report (EL PAÍS English, 2026). Our earlier coverage of this Fourth Circuit ruling and what it sets up is available here.

The legal fight turns on how ICE has read an immigration law since July 2025 (EL PAÍS English, 2026). Until the high court acts, the rules depend on where a person is detained.

---

4. Maryland Leaders Want Answers After Baton Video

Political leaders in Maryland are calling for investigations into ICE officers’ conduct after clashes with protesters during a federal operation in Frederick, about 50 miles northwest of Baltimore (The Guardian, 2026).

Video footage shows officers using batons on members of the public and driving vehicles onto the sidewalk toward people, more than a week after ICE arrived in numerous vehicles (The Guardian, 2026).

What witnesses describe

Protesters sat down in a line across the road, linked arms and tried to block the doorway of a residential address as ICE personnel approached. Officers went inside the home but left without appearing to have made any arrests (The Guardian, 2026).

Cesar Diaz, president of the Frederick city council, said he rushed to the scene. “I had to move so I wouldn’t get hit, and the vice-president did too,” he said, referring to council vice-president Katie Nash. “There was no warning at all. The vehicle was one foot away from her” (The Guardian, 2026).

Diaz estimated about 200 protesters gathered, with four or five ICE vehicles present at first and eight or nine by Thursday evening (The Guardian, 2026).

Witnesses said some residents were scared to leave home for work, and some needed help making sure children stepping off the school bus on Thursday afternoon got home safely (The Guardian, 2026).

Protesters chanted “Go home,” “Leave Frederick” and “Leave Maryland” at the federal personnel (The Guardian, 2026).

For people navigating checkpoints and enforcement activity close to home, we’ve compiled practical steps for traveling and moving about safely right now.

---

What’s Disputed or Unconfirmed

The Frederick clashes: The Guardian’s report includes the beginning of an ICE statement (“ICE said in…”) but no full agency response is available in our source material. Any account of what ICE says happened should be taken directly from the agency.

The Washington arrests: The claim that ICE targeted campers comes from the families of the five men, not from ICE. No agency account appears in the source material, so the circumstances of the arrests remain one-sided in what we reviewed.

The Pennsylvania raid: The number of people detained and where they are being held are not stated. Local reporting attributes the detention to ICE but does not specify charges or custody location.

The bond ruling: The Fourth Circuit decision was 2-1, meaning one judge dissented. Two other appeals courts have sided with the government, so the legal question is unsettled nationwide and could still reach the Supreme Court (EL PAÍS English, 2026).

---

How to Verify This Yourself

• Check ICE’s newsroom for agency statements and enforcement press releases on the Montour County and Washington cases.
• Pull the Fourth Circuit opinion and Judge Berner’s majority directly from the court’s docket to read the full ruling and the dissent.
• For Frederick, read the Frederick city council’s public statements and local Maryland outlets, and compare them with any ICE release.
• For detention conditions, review Department of Homeland Security Office of Inspector General reports and the NBC News report on the El Paso exhibit.

---

---

References

1. MSN. (2026, September 11). ICE raid targets construction project in central Pennsylvania. msn.com
2. MSN. (2026, September 12). Forest Service rangers helped ICE arrest 5 campers in Washington. msn.com
3. NBC News. (2026, September 12). What’s it like to be detained in an ICE facility? An immersive exhibit tries to explain. nbcnews.com
4. EL PAÍS English. (2026, September 11). Another US court rejects detention of some migrants without the right to a bail hearing. english.elpais.com
5. The Guardian. (2026, September 12). Calls for investigation after video shows ICE officers using batons on protesters. theguardian.com

---